Ten great
female philosophers: The thinking woman's women
Radio 4's 'Greatest Philosopher' poll yielded an all-male Top
20. But is philosophy really a female-free zone? On the contrary, insists
Camille Paglia - and here are 10 to prove the point
14 July 2005
For most of history, the groundbreaking philosophers have all been men, and
philosophy has always been a male genre. Women had neither the education nor
the time to pursue the life of the mind. In modern times, especially in the
past 200 years, women have made immense cultural contributions - but much
more to literature and the arts than to philosophy. Their absence from the
BBC Radio 4's "Great Philosophers" poll needs to be explained.
I feel women in general are less comfortable than men in inhabiting a highly
austere, cold, analytical space, such as the one which philosophy involves.
Women as a whole - and there are obvious exceptions - are more drawn to
practical, personal matters. It is not that they inherently lack a talent or
aptitude for philosophy or higher mathematics, but rather that they are more
unwilling than men to devote their lives to a frigid space from which the
natural and the human have been eliminated.
Now that women have at last gained access to higher education, we are
waiting to see what they can achieve in the fields where men have
distinguished themselves, above all in philosophy. At the moment, however,
the genre of philosophy is not flourishing; systematic reasoning no longer
has the prestige or cultural value that it once had. The entire way we
approach the world has changed. Philosophy once claimed to provide a
rigorous method to search for the meaning of life, and it was a precious
substitute for dogmatic religion. But in modern times, religion among the
educated classes in Europe and North America has lost ground, and
intellectuals are neglecting the basic human need to find answers.
Philosophers are now at the margin. Philosophy has shrunk in reputation and
stature - it's an academic exercise.
The last truly important movement in the world of philosophy was
existentialism, in the post-war Paris of Jean-Paul Sartre, Albert Camus and
Simone de Beauvoir. There have been theories of language since then, but
without the profound insight of the best philosophy. Post-structuralism and
post-modernism, by their slippery relativism, have destroyed the concept of
philosophy. No one cares about philosophers - cultural criticism has come to
the fore. Media and glitzy pop culture dominate now, and people need help to
negotiate and survive it.
The term "female philosopher" doesn't even make sense to me. Simone de
Beauvoir was a thinker rather than a philosopher. A philosopher for me is
someone who is removed from everyday concerns and manipulates terms and
concepts like counters on a grid or chessboard. Both Simone de Beauvoir and
Ayn Rand, another favourite of mine, have their own highly influential
system of thought, and therefore they belong on any list of great
philosophers.
Rand's mix of theory, social observations and commentary was very original,
though we see her Romantic sources. Her system is broad and complex and well
deserves to be incorporated into the philosophy curriculum.
Simone de Beauvoir's magnum opus, The Second Sex (which hugely influenced me
in my youth), demonstrates her hybrid consciousness. It doesn't conform to
the strict definition of philosophy because it's an amalgamation of abstract
thought and history and anthropology - real facts. The genre problem is
probably why both these women are absent from the list. But Plato too was a
writer of dramatic fiction--so that it is no basis for dismissing Rand.
The term philosopher is pass, anyhow, and should be abandoned. The thinker
of modern times should be partly abstract and partly practical. Karl Marx,
the winner of the Radio 4 poll yesterday , was indeed a truly major thinker.
He was not a captive of abstraction and always kept his eye on society and
its evolution.But for me his failures emanated
from his indifference to the individual and his ruthless privileging of the
group.
It has become tiresome to constantly blame every blip in women's lives on
sexism and discrimination by men. Today's lack of major female philosophers
is not due to lack of talent but to the collapse of philosophy.
Philosophy as traditionally practised may be a dead genre.
This is the age of the internet in which we are constantly flooded by
information in fragments. Each person at the computer is embarked on a quest
for and fabrication of his or her identity. The web mimics human neurology,
and it is fundamentally altering young people's brains. The web, for good or
ill, is instantaneous. Philosophy belongs to a vanished age of much slower
and rhetorically formal inquiry.
Today's philosophers are now antiquarians.
The author is Professor of Humanities at the University of the Arts,
Philadelphia. Her latest book, "Break, Blow, Burn: Camille Paglia Reads
Forty-Three of the World's Best Poems" is out now (11.50, Pantheon)
Hannah Arendt: 1906-1975
German-born Jewish philosopher who studied under Heidegger (with whom she
also had a brief relationship) before being imprisoned by the Gestapo in
1933 for her work on anti-Semitic propaganda.
She escaped and fled to Paris; seven years later, following the fall of
France, she moved to the US. Initial interests in existentialism and in the
thought of St Augustine gave place to a more political awareness. She is
best known for The Origins of Totalitarianism (1951), as well as for her
coverage of Adolf Eichmann's trial (published first in The New Yorker and
then in her 1963 book, Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of
Evil). Her justification for capital punishment in Eichmann's case was that,
as Eichmann had not wanted to share the earth with the Jews, the Jewish
state had no reason to share the earth with him. The first two volumes of
her projected three-volume Life of the Mind were published posthumously, as
was her Reflections on Kant's Political Philosophy.
Hypatia of Alexandria: C370-415AD
Follower of Plotinius who developed neo-Platonism at Alexandria from about
400 to her death in 415. She was so well-known, apparently, that
correspondence addressed only to "The Philosopher" is said to have reached
her.
Also a leading mathematician and astronomer, she is thought to have taught
ideas relating to different levels of reality and humanity's ability to
understand them. She seems to have believed that everything in the natural
world emanates from "the one" - and that human beings lack the mental
capacity fully to comprehend ult imate reality.
Her subsequent obscurity probably reflects the fact that none of her work
survives (although letters from a pupil do). It appears, however, that her
influence made the city's Christian community feel threatened - perhaps
partly because of her emphasis on the value of science. She was torn to
death by a Christian mob (including monks armed with oyster shells).
Admirers revere her as a philosophical martyr comparable to Socrates.
Simone de Beauvoir: 1908-1986
Undeservedly overshadowed by her lover, Jean-Paul Sartre, Beauvoir developed
an education in traditional philosophy (she wrote a thesis on Leibniz) into
more radical explorations of feminism and existentialism.
Some of her ideas - about human freedom, for example, and about
"being-for-itself" and "being-in-itself" - overlapped with Sartre's, but her
best philosophical work, such as The Ethics of Ambiguity (1948), was
important in its own right, as was her towering work of feminist ideology,
The Second Sex (1949). In The Second Sex, Beauvoir argues that women have
been held back throughout history by the perception that they are a
"deviation" from the male norm - an assumption that must be broken if
feminism is to succeed.
Elizabeth Anscombe: 1919-2001
Oxbridge-rooted academic principally concerned with defining the actual
nature of phenomena such as mind and morality, Gertrude Elizabeth Margaret
Anscombe has been described as the pre-eminent British philosopher of the
20th century. She had intellectual roots not only in classical philosophy
but also in Roman Catholicism and in the modern philosophy of Wittgenstein
and Frege. A friend of Wittgenstein, she produced the definitive (and still
unrevised) translation of his Philosophical Investigations in 1953, as well
theIntroduction to Wittgenstein's Tractatus in 1959. Her Intention (1957) is
considered to be the founding document of modern "action theory". An
analytical philosopher of exceptional rigour, she allegedly once said to A J
Ayer: "If you didn't talk so quickly, people wouldn't think you were so
clever"; to which the philosopher replied: "If you didn't talk so slowly,
people wouldn't think you were so profound."
Anne, Lady Conway: 1631-1679
An English follower of Descartes with an interest in the kabbala and, later,
Quakerism.
Born Anne Finch, she studied philosophy secondhand - via her brother - under
Henry More at Cambridge. Her sex debarred her from studying the subject
herself, but she corresponded with More for most of her relatively short
life - she died at the age of 47.
Preoccupied with the question of substance - she doubted the existence of
inert matter - she developed a God-based theory of nature as an integrated
mental and material order ("life and figure are distinct attributes of one
substance"), made up of individual "monads".
In this, she anticipated Leibniz, who acknowledged her as an influence. Her
one surviving work, Principles of the Most Ancient and Modern Philosophy,
was published posthumously (and anonymously) in 1690.
Anne Conway suffered from severe migraines and is said to have considered
the operation known as trepanning as a possible cure.
Sarah Margaret Fuller: 1810-1850
US-born feminist and champion of transcendental idealism, whose Woman of the
Nineteenth Century was America's first major feminist manifesto. A pupil of
Emerson, she taught in Rhode Island and Boston before moving to Europe in
1846 and marrying an Italian aristocrat. Together with her husband and son,
she drowned off Fire Island, New York, after fleeing the Italian revolution.
Susan Haack: 1945-
British-born professor of philosophy and law at the University of Miami.
Inhabits the difficult end of the spectrum, propounding an epistemological
theory called foundherentism, a kind of Third Way between foundationalism
and coherentism. (If you need to ask, you wouldn't understand.) Works
include: Deviant Logic (1974), Philosophy of Logics (1978), and Defending
Science - Within Reason Between Scientism and Cynicism (2003).
Mary Wollstonecraft: 1759-1797
English feminist and egalitarian, associated with Thomas Paine and William
Godwin (her husband). A Vindication of the Rights of Men (1790) argued
against the slave trade; A Vindication of the Rights of Women (1792) did
what it said on the jacket. Described marriage as "legal prostitution".
Opposed monarchy, church and military. Died after giving birth to the future
Mary Shelley.
Ayn Rand: 1905-1982
Controversial Russian novelist and philosopher, a "radical capitalist" whose
works are popular with young Tories (and Camille Paglia). Moved to US in
1924 and developed a philosophy of individualism she called Objectivism ("a
philosophy for living on earth"). Best-known works: The Fountainhead (1935)
and Atlas Shrugged (1957). Appeared in a Tobias Wolff memoir, and was played
by Helen Mirren in a 1999 film about her life.
Dame Mary Warnock: 1924-
Mary Warnock has significantly more influence on the way British society
thinks of itself than any living male philosopher. She is a champion of a
woman's right to philosophise. A veteran of royal commissions and committees
of inquiry, she has published (among much else) The Uses of Philosophy
(1992), and Women Philosophers (1996).
Profiles by Ellie Levenson
Forget the glass ceiling
A ceremony
held last night honoured ten ofBritain's most
remarkable women. Arifa Akbar reports on a group oftrail-blazers who broke the mould
09 June 2005
Dr Gill Samuels, Science
As the director of vascular biology at Pfizer, Ms Samuels, 60, oversaw thediscovery of compounds for reducing hypertension and migraines. But
perhaps
most famously, she was part of the 1,000-strong team which invented Viagra.
The discovery, she said, came in 1985 after 13 years of intense team workand laboratory experiments. She said: "We were looking at various
disorders
in vasular contraction when we came across this new class of compound thatcould relax blood vessels. I have heard people call it a lifestyle
drug butI don't think of it like that. It has
caused men to think differently abouttheir
health. It has de-stigmatised erectile health and as someone who hadto review all the letters of patients, who say 'It has stopped me
killingmyself' or 'It has stopped me hitting my
wife', that I realise what a goodmedicine it is,"
she said.
The granddaughter of a Shropshire coalminer, Ms Samuels' early love ofscience was encouraged by her parents, not least because her own
father wasa chemist.
"I have always been curious about how things worked. I was one of thosechildren that loved to demolish dolls to see how they were put
together andmy parents did not distinguish in the
educational choices of my brother ormyself. They
supported us both. Science is a bit like cooking - and mycooking has always been a bit experimental," she said.
After completing a PhD, she began working in industry and joined Pfizer 27years ago. While she has never felt she has "bumped my head against a
glass
ceiling", she stressed that girls needed role models and ambassadors both inthe world of business as well as science.
In spite of her many ground-breaking discoveries, she said she has had herfair share of scientific disappointments. "You have to be tenacious
as wellas a good scientist. You have to be highly
motivated and learn to cope withthe ups and
downs, the disappointments as well as the excitements.Scientists have to be highly motivated to keep working on something
thatwill make a difference," she said.
She said there was a need to retain women in science, who tend to leave inthe thirties to raise families. "Whenever you look in science, there
are alot of women who come in at the beginning
but around their thirties, numbersof women start
to decrease. It is clear we cannot afford to lose goodscientists with brains. There must be ways we can keep women in
science.
"Pfizer's diversity programme focuses on getting the best people and keepingthem, and if they have a period off work so they can have a family,
it isabout making sure all the options are there
on return, such as flexibleworking hours and
shared jobs."
She was praised by the judges for making an extraordinary contribution toscience in terms of policy and public awareness. Pfizer colleagues
said shealways emanated an infectious enthusiasm
and remains one of the greatestinspirations to
women in science.
Nobel laureate Marie Curie was nominated to the French Academy of Sciences
in 1910. After heated debate, the Academy turned her down by only two votes.
That was so close that the members voted again -- this time to decide
whether women should ever be admitted. Women in general fared worse than Mme
Curie in particular. She'd barely lost, but the Academy voted resoundingly
-- 90 to 52 -- to bar women completely.
Marie Curie won her second Nobel prize a year later, but the French Academy
stuck to its guns. It didn't break down and admit a woman until 1979. The
English record is not much better. Before 1945, the only woman in the
British Royal Society was a skeleton in its anatomical display.
Still, modern science itself has put the question of intellectual equality
under a lens. The question arose quite naturally as science took shape in
the 17th century. Londa Shiebinger shows how science has twisted and turned
in its struggle with the fact of female intelligence.
Some scientists thought a woman's skull wouldn't accommodate as much brain
as a man's. A 17th-century woman scientist said that the female mind was too
"soft" and "cold" for hard thought. One 19th-century opinion was that
thought shriveled a woman's ovaries. And you've heard recent claims that
women don't have the same access to right-brain creativity that men do.
2500 years ago, Plato argued from pure reason that "all the pursuits of men
are the pursuits of women," that men and women are intellectually the same.
In 1673, a Cartesian anatomist, Francois Poullain, echoed Plato. He made the
oddly unassailable statement that "the mind has no sex." His remark has
haunted failed attempts to prove the mental frailty of women ever since.
Two doors opened to women in the early days of modern science. One was
Italy. University faculties at both Padua and Bologna included distinguished
women. And, for some reason, about a sixth of the early German astronomers
were women. The tradition of women lecturers was an old one at Bologna, by
the way. In 1296 Bettisia Gozzadini taught law there. But we're told that
she lectured from behind a curtain so her great beauty wouldn't distract
students.
So we peel away the curtains that history has drawn over women who've lived
the life of the mind. What we find is a continuing presence. When women were
thwarted here, they emerged there. In the end we learn that the mind hasn't
been such an easy thing to waste, after all.
Don't know if this piece is genuine
(anyone out there with back issues of this magazine who could confirm this?)
:
Well, here's a surprisingly unusual
viewpoint:
Why women are poor at science, by Harvard president
Suzanne Goldenberg in Washington
Tuesday January 18 2005
The Guardian
The president of Harvard University has provoked a furore by arguing
that men outperform women in maths and sciences because of biological
difference, and discrimination is no longer a career barrier for female
academics.
Lawrence Summers, a career economist who served as treasury secretary under
President Clinton, has a reputation for outspokenness. His tenure at Harvard
has been marked by clashes with African-American staff and leftwing
intellectuals, and complaints about a fall in the hiring of women.
He made his remarks at a private conference on the position of women and
minorities in science and engineering, hosted by the National Bureau of
Economic Research.
In a lengthy address delivered without notes, Dr Summers offered three
explanations for the shortage of women in senior posts in science and
engineering, starting with their reluctance to work long hours because of
childcare responsibilities.
He went on to argue that boys outperform girls on high school science and
maths scores because of genetic difference. "Research in behavioural
genetics is showing that things people previously attributed to
socialisation weren't due to socialisation after all," he told the Boston
Globe yesterday.
As an example, Dr Summers told the conference about giving his daughter two
trucks. She treated them like dolls, and named them mummy and daddy trucks,
he said.
Dr Summers also played down the impact of sex bias in appointments to
academic institutions.
He said: "The real issue is the overall size of the pool, and it's less
clear how much the size of the pool was held down by discrimination."
At least half of his audience comprised women, several said they found the
remarks offensive and one walked out.
"It was really shocking to hear the president of Harvard make statements
like that," said Denice Denton, who is about to become president of the
University of California at Santa Cruz.
Others said Dr Summers's comments were depressingly familiar. "I have heard
men make comments like this my entire life and quite honestly if I had
listened to them I would never have done anything," said Donna Nelson, a
chemistry professor at the University of Oklahoma.
A Harvard spokeswoman declined to comment yesterday, or to release the
transcript of Dr Summers's remarks. Richard Freeman, who invited the
Harvard president to speak at the conference, said Dr Summers's comments
were intended to provoke debate, and some women over-reacted.
"Some people took offence because they were very sensitive," said Dr
Freeman, an economist at Harvard and the London School of Economics. "It
does not seem to me insane to think that men and women have biological
differences."
During Dr Summers's presidency, the number of tenured jobs offered to women
has fallen from 36% to 13%. Last year, only four of 32 tenured job openings
were offered to women.
And an
interesting retort:
Female astronomers connected the
dots
By Simon Singh, Globe Correspondent
February 1, 2005
When Harvard president Lawrence
H. Summers suggested that there might be ''innate" differences between women
and men that affect their success in the sciences, it brought to mind an
extraordinary story concerning women scientists at Harvard at the start of
the 20th century.
In 1877, Edward Pickering became
director of the Harvard College Observatory and initiated a relentless
program of photographing the night sky. The observatory would take a
half-million photographic plates in the decades to come, so one of
Pickering's biggest challenges was to establish an industrial-scale system
for analyzing them. Each plate contained hundreds of stars, and each speck
would need to have its brightness evaluated and its location measured.
Pickering, who led the observatory
for 42 years, recruited a team of young women to act as computers, a term
originally used to describe people who manipulated data and performed
calculations. It was menial work in a field of research from which women
were otherwise excluded. It was then unthinkable that women would be allowed
to stay up through the night staring through telescopes in the freezing
cold.
Nevertheless, these mostly
untrained women (known as "Pickering's harem") were able to make an enormous
contribution to astronomy. They had brilliant minds and gained an intimate
knowledge of the data, so they were able to make astounding discoveries.
For example, Williamina Fleming was
a single mother struggling to survive when she became an employee at the
observatory in 1879, but she went on to find 10 of the 24 novas then known.
Annie Jump Cannon made a major
contribution to stellar classification, establishing a system that, with
only minor modifications, is still in use. She divided stars into seven
classes -- O, B, A, F, G, K, M. Today's undergraduates learn these stellar
classifications according to the mnemonic ''Oh, Be A Fine Girl -- Kiss Me!"
In 1925, Cannon became the first
woman to receive an honorary doctorate from Oxford University. She also was
voted one of the 12 greatest American women in 1931, and the same year
became the first woman to receive the prestigious Draper Gold Medal from the
American National Academy of Sciences.
Cannon had been struck down by
scarlet fever as a child, which left her almost deaf. The most famous member
of Pickering's harem, Henrietta Leavitt, was also profoundly deaf. Leavitt
was born in 1868 in Lancaster. In 1892, she graduated from Harvard
University's Radcliffe College, and later went on to become a volunteer at
Harvard College Observatory. She spent several years sifting through the
photographic plates searching for variable stars, which she had been asked
to catalog. Variable stars, as the name suggests, have the unusual property
of growing brighter and then fading over the course of a few nights or a few
weeks. Leavitt would discover more than 2,400 variable stars, about half of
the total known in her day. Professor Charles Young of Princeton University
was so impressed that he called her ''a variable-star fiend."
Of the different types of variable
stars, Leavitt developed a particular passion for so-called Cepheid
variables. After months spent measuring Cepheid variables, she realized that
it would be possible to work out the actual brightness of a Cepheid variable
star based on how quickly it went from bright to dim and back to bright
again. Astronomers previously did not know if a star was dim and close up or
bright and far away, but Leavitt could answer this question with respect to
Cepheids.
This was an incredible breakthrough
because, once Leavitt had shown astronomers how they could measure the
actual brightness of Cepheid variables, it enabled them to measure the
distances to these stars and to effectively measure the distances across the
cosmos.
Leavitt's discovery transformed
astronomy and ultimately laid the foundations for men like Edwin Hubble to
find the first evidence in favor of the big-bang model of the universe.
While Hubble and other successful
male astronomers gained great fame, Leavitt and her colleagues largely have
been forgotten.
Simon Singh is the author of ''Big
Bang," a history of cosmology.
Sex, Time
and Power BIG
BRAIN, NARROW PELVIS By
Leonard Shlain
Since our
genetic makeup has changed very little in the last 150,000 years, I will
make the key assumption that the main features of modern men's and women's
reproductive life histories do not differ substantially from those present
at the outset of our species. There can be no doubt that culture can affect
sexual behaviors, but the features I will be referring to are more basic.
For example, I assume that the average length of a contemporary woman's
menstrual cycle and that of a current man's obsession with sex are both
innate traits that ancestral humans exhibited. (To engage in these
speculations, I will make a series of generalizations about men and women.
Describing only the crest of the bell-shaped distribution curve of both male
and female human behavior, I will not list the many, many exceptions that
exist. As a place to begin, let us suspend judgment temporarily and assume
these premises are reasonable).
I will
hypothesize that the male's behavior evolved soon afterward in response to
the female's lead. In fact, I will argue that the history of our species
could be written from the perspective that males have spent the last 150,000
years trying to regain the power they so emphatically lost to females when
we differentiated away from Homo erectus. By examining the habits of modern
human males and females, we can infer the many changes that emerged when the
new, improved Homo sapiens female debuted in Nature's garden.
The
catalogue begins with the absence in Eve's daughters of some sort of signal
that would inform a male that they were ovulating. Unlike the vast majority
of other females, the one belonging to the human line does not advertise her
ovulatory burst. With very few exceptions, other species' females have a
distinct period of sexual receptivity during which they experience a
powerful instinctual drive to mate. To the males of her species, a female
emanates a distinctive "green light," whether olfactory, visual, auditory,
gestural, or some combination thereof. These episodic heights of female
sexual desire are exquisitely timed to coincide with her ovulation.
Previously uninterested males are alerted by her attention-grabbing signals.
Estrus, as
this upsurge is called in female primates, promotes harmony between the
sexes. When both male and female are equally excited about mating, it is
likely that they will have an amicable and mutually rewarding encounter.
Obviously, a considerable benefit accrues to the species if mating occurs in
synchrony with ovulation. Sperm meets ovum, and conception occurs. Eve's
daughters, however, lack this most basic sexual semaphore, having replaced
it with concealed ovulation. Human ovulation is so cryptic that most women
remain unaware when, precisely, their eggs have departed from their ovaries.
Further
obscuring the timing of her ovulation, the human female acquired the
potential to engage in sex, if she desired, 365 days of the year, during
pregnancy, lactation, menstruation, and even after menopause. [Bonobos, a
kind of chimpanzee, also engage in sex nearly continually. Nevertheless,
females signal through smell and visual displays when they are in estrus,
even if that estrus lasts two weeks of their six-week cycle. Ninety percent
of bonobo sexual penetrations take place within their estrual period.]
An
alternative way to state this unusual condition would be to say that the
human female does not experience a distinct period of estrus because she is
in a state of constant estrus. Precious few other species' females could
hold a candle to the human female in this department. No other species has
so definitively uncoupled sex and reproduction as the human line. Since sex
is so intricately intertwined with reproduction in the other three million
sexually active species, what would have been the reason that Natural
Selection abandoned this successful strategy in humans?
Another
innovation: Some human females experienced a prolonged orgasm capable of
multiple sustained repeats. Orgasms, both male and female, are intensely
subjective, and we cannot measure with confidence the degree of other female
species' orgasms. And yet no nonhuman female, in her observable behavior,
comes anywhere near to attaining the heights of sexual pleasure manifested
by a woman in the throes of her orgasm.
The male's
orgasm, in human and other species, is a necessary component of his
ejaculation. It is followed by his rapid withdrawal and prompt
disengagement. Only in the human can the female notify the male through
vocal or body language, after the completion of his delivery call, that she
is not finished, and that she expects him to continue until further notice.
Moreover,
the variety of sexual positions used in human intercourse exceeds that of
virtually all other species. Women became the first land females to
habitually copulate face to face with their partners, and they became the
first females to increasingly take advantage of an alternative position:
mounting a supine male. [Stump-tailed monkeys and bonobos also use these
positions on occasion, but a male mounting from the rear of the female
remains their preference.]
Another
feature of human sexuality is the prolonged period of sexual foreplay that
occurs prior to penetration. Many other species engage in elaborate mating
and courting rituals. However, when they finally get down to business,
sexual foreplay is virtually nonexistent. The human male, in contrast, seems
to have grasped the key fact somewhere along the line that it was in his
best interests to expend considerable time and effort preparing his partner
so that she, too, could experience pleasure. Concern for the pleasure of the
female he is preparing to penetrate is not a motive that one would impute to
the amatory repertoires of any other species' males. [Again, male bonobos
also exhibit this behavior to a limited degree, and chimpanzee males will
groom a female who is pregnant or lactating in the expectation that when she
comes into estrus again she will be more receptive to him.]
Biologists
estimate that there are between ten million and thirty million different
species of life-forms on earth today. Of these, four thousand are mammals.
Only one among the four thousand experiences significant blood loss on a
regular basis. If conception does not occur, a fertile human female sheds
the lining of her uterus along with approximately forty to eighty
milliliters (several tablespoons) of blood every four weeks. A few other
mammals--for example, hedgehogs, bats, shrews and elephants--show signs of
menses, but for all of them it is a relative nonevent. Primatologist Alison
Jolly estimates that there are approximately 270 different species of
primates. Only thirty-one species of primates menstruate. All of these but
one, a human, lose an insignificant quantity of blood.
Blood is an
essential fluid. What conceivable benefit could female blood loss have
conferred on the survival of our species? Something as dramatic as monthly
menstrual bleeding must somehow be accounted for in the evolutionary scheme
of things.
Although it
is possible that menses is an incidental spandrel related to some other
adaptation, it looms so large as a constant in the life of every woman that
it is unlikely to be a mere accident of nature. (Some anthropologists have
raised the point that ancestral women rarely menstruated because they were
either pregnant, lactating or menopausal.)
Adding to
the enigma of human menses is the human females' propensity to coordinate
their menses with other women, a feature rarely observed in nonhuman primate
females. Like the tines of disparate tuning forks all resonating to the same
note, women involuntarily tend to synchronize their periods when they live
or work together in offices, convents, dormitories and large families.
Ancestral women lived in tight-knit clans numbering around twenty to thirty
fecund women. It is likely that these women, too, synchronized their
periods. One suspects it is a very old adaptation that once served an
important function in our species' development.
An
unexpected component of human females' synchronized menses is that the
conductor orchestrating this harmony is an inert 81,000,000,000,000,000,000-
(eighty-one-quintillion) ton object located 250,000 miles out in space. The
moon is the metronome that sets the tempo for cycles that begin to vibrate
in unison in the dark interiors of billions of women's pelvises each month.
It is likely that ancestral women, too, entrained their menses with the
lunar orbit.
During the
past century, technology has flooded our lives with artificial light.
Fluorescent and electric lightbulbs have illuminated what had previously
been darkness. Moonlight is no longer the critical illumination it once was.
Most people are unaware of the current status of the moon's phases. Yet most
women continue to coordinate their menstrual cycles with the lunar ones.
Another
anomaly of the human female's sexual life cycle is her menopause. A woman
stops ovulating at an earlier point in her life than any other female
mammal, while coincidentally acquiring the distinction of becoming the
longest-lived terrestrial mammal. [Some bowhead whales have been estimated
to live to 150 years.]
If she
avoids maternal mortality and other female causes of an early demise, a
woman can on rare occasions achieve a life span exceeding a hundred years.
The human female was clearly built to last. At present in the United States,
she outlives her male counterpart by an average of six years, while
attaining an average life span of eighty-three years.
A
postmenopausal woman possesses a longer period of life during which she is
incapable of conceiving a new life than any other female mammals, even
though she remains quite vigorous for most of these years. With very few
exceptions, other mammalian females ovulate right up to the day they die.
And a woman stands in stark contrast to a man, who, despite advanced age and
many infirmities, usually can generate viable sperm far into his dotage.
Another baffling feature of human menopause: Despite the early cutoff in
their reproductive faculty, some menopausal women report an increased
libido. If the purpose of sex is the continuation of the species through
reproduction, why, only in the human line, did early cessation of ovarian
function combine with longevity and increased libidinous desire?
The
innovations distinguishing the human female from other mammalian females
mentioned thus far pale when compared with her most spectacular new feature.
She became the first species who possessed the willpower to refuse
consistently to engage in sex around the time she was ovulating. For that
matter, she was the first animal of either sex, of any species, capable of
deciding to remain celibate if she so desired.
This resolve
is the heart of Response W. This is the gift Natural Selection bestowed upon
her for having to endure Factor X, high maternal mortality and painful
childbirth. It is something that had heretofore never existed in the animal
kingdom. Philosophers call it Free Will. And herein lies the crux of
relations between the sexes. African Eve and her daughters developed the
determination to choose consciously a course of action that overrode the
instinctual circuits that drive every other species' females to copulate
when they ovulate. Females of some other species may be able to choose which
male among multiple suitors upon which they wish to confer their favors; an
occasional female of any species may decide not to mate with anyone or at
any time. But the human species was the first in which all the females
evolved the capacity to decide consciously to refuse to mate during any one
ovulation or all the time.
-------------------------
Leonard
Shlain is the Chairman of Laparoscopic surgery at the California Pacific
Medical Center in San Francisco and is an Associate Professor of Surgery at
UCSF. He is also the author of "Art & Physics: Parallel Visions in Space,
Time, and Light" (HarperCollins, 1991) and "The Alphabet Versus The Goddess:
The Conflict Between Word and Image" (Viking, 1998). The essay above is from
his most recent book, "Sex,
Time and Power " (Viking, 2003), which explores how women's sexuality
shaped human evolution. Dr. Shlain lectures widely both in the United States
and throughout Europe. He lives and writes in Mill Valley, California.
Women like silent men. They think they're listening. ~Marcel Achard,
Quote, 4 November 1956
Sure God created man before woman. But then you always make a rough draft
before the final masterpiece. ~Author Unknown
Some men know that a light touch of the tongue, running from a woman's toes
to her ears, lingering in the softest way possible in various places in
between, given often enough and sincerely enough, would add immeasurably to
world peace. ~Marianne Williamson, "A Woman's Worth"
Women cannot complain about men anymore until they start getting better
taste in them. ~Bill Maher
A male gynecologist is like an auto mechanic who has never owned a car.
~Carrie Snow
You start out happy that you have no hips or boobs. All of a sudden you get
them, and it feels sloppy. Then just when you start liking them, they start
drooping. ~Cindy Crawford
Every girl should use what Mother Nature gave her before Father Time takes
it away. ~Laurence J. Peter
The average woman would rather have beauty than brains, because the average
man can see better than he can think. ~Author Unknown
A woman can say more in a sigh than a man can say in a sermon. ~Arnold
Haultain
Whatever women do they must do twice as well as men to be thought half as
good. Luckily, this is not difficult. ~Charlotte Whitton
The two women exchanged the kind of glance women use when no knife is
handy. ~Ellery Queen
Curve: The loveliest distance between two points. ~Mae West
Can you imagine a world without men? No crime and lots of happy fat women.
~Nicole Hollander
Women get the last word in every argument. Anything a man says after that
is the beginning of a new argument. ~Author Unknown
Next to the wound, what women make best is the bandage. ~Jules Barbey
d'Aurevilly
A pessimist is a man who thinks all women are bad. An optimist is a man who
hopes they are. ~Chauncey Mitchell Depew
The rarest thing in the world is a woman who is pleased with photographs of
herself. ~Elizabeth Metcalf
A man's face is his autobiography. A woman's face is her work of fiction.
~Oscar Wilde
There's something luxurious about having a girl light your cigarette. In
fact, I got married once on account of that. ~Harold Robbins
When a man talks dirty to a woman, it's sexual harassment. When a woman
talks dirty to a man, it's $3.95 a minute. ~Author Unknown
Men get laid, but women get screwed. ~Quentin Crisp
The most popular image of the female despite the exigencies of the clothing
trade is all boobs and buttocks, a hallucinating sequence of parabolae and
bulges. ~Germaine Greer
Whether they give or refuse, it delights women just the same to have been
asked. ~Ovid
Howiver, I'm not denyin' the women are foolish: God Almighty made 'em to
match the men. ~George Eliot, "The Harvest Supper," Adam Bede
Women are like elephants to me. I like to look at them, but I wouldn't want
to own one. ~W.C. Fields
Women really do rule the world. They just haven't figured it out yet. When
they do, and they will, we're all in big big trouble. ~"Doctor" Leon of
drleons.com
Ah, women. They make the highs higher and the lows more frequent. ~Author
Unknown
I expect Woman will be the last thing civilized by Man. ~George Meredith
Men who don't like girls with brains don't like girls. ~Mignon McLaughlin,
The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
Women keep a special corner of their hearts for sins they have never
committed. ~Cornelia Otis Skinner
Lovely female shapes are terrible complicators of the difficulties and
dangers of this earthly life, especially for their owners. ~George du
Maurier
Every woman is wrong until she cries, and then she is right - instantly.
~Sam Slick (Thomas Chandler Haliburton)
Men have been trained and conditioned by women, not unlike the way Pavlov
conditioned his dogs, into becoming their slaves. As compensation for their
labours men are given periodic use of a woman's vagina. ~Esther Vilar
The essence of life is the smile of round female bottoms, under the shadow
of cosmic boredom. ~Guy de Maupassant
I have an idea that the phrase "weaker sex" was coined by some woman to
disarm some man she was preparing to overwhelm. ~Ogden Nash
When men reach their sixties and retire, they go to pieces. Women go right
on cooking. ~Gail Sheehy
The torment that so many young women know, bound hand and foot by love and
motherhood, without having forgotten their former dreams. ~Simone de
Beauvoir
They call it PMS because Mad Cow Disease was already taken. ~Author Unknown
Be to her virtues very kind,
Be to her faults a little blind.
~Matthew Prior
They may talk of a comet, or a burning mountain, or some such bagatelle; but
to me a modest woman, dressed out in all her finery, is the most tremendous
object of the whole creation. ~Oliver Goldsmith
A highbrow is a man who has found something more interesting than women.
~Edgar Wallace
It upsets women to be, or not to be, stared at hungrily. ~Mignon
McLaughlin, The Neurotic's Notebook, 1960
You see, dear, it is not true that woman was made from man's rib; she was
really made from his funny bone. ~J.M. Barrie, What Every Woman Knows
If women didn't exist, all the money in the world would have no meaning.
~Aristotle Onassis
Men will always delight in a woman whose voice is lined with velvet.
~Brendan Francis
Men really prefer reasonably attractive women; they go after the sensational
ones to impress other men. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's
Notebook, 1966
I married beneath me - all women do. ~Nancy Astor, speech, Oldham, England,
1951
Women are never stronger than when they arm themselves with their weakness.
~Marie de Vichy-Chamrond, Marquise du Deffand, Letters to Voltaire
Women dress alike all over the world: they dress to be annoying to other
women. ~Elsa Schiaparelli
If President Nixon's secretary, Rosemary Woods, had been Moses' secretary,
there would only be eight commandments. ~Art Buchwald, 1974
Woman begins by resisting a man's advances and ends by blocking his
retreat. ~Oscar Wilde
She wore a short skirt and a tight sweater and her figure described a set of
parabolas that could cause cardiac arrest in a yak. ~Woody Allen,
Getting Even, 1973
It is only rarely that one can see in a little boy the promise of a man, but
one can almost always see in a little girl the threat of a woman. ~Alexandre
Dumas, fils
I'd rather have two girls at seventeen than one at thirty-four. ~Fred Allen
When a woman comes to her glass, she does not employ her time in making
herself look more advantageously what she really is, but endeavours to be as
much another creature as she possibly can. Whether this happens because
they stay so long and attend their work so diligently that they forget the
faces and persons which they first sat down with, or whatever it is, they
seldom rise from the toilet the same woman they appeared when they began to
dress. ~Joseph Addison
All women are basically in competition with each other for a handful of
eligible men. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook,
1966
A woman should soften but not weaken a man. ~Sigmund Freud
Women are in league with each other, a secret conspiracy of hearts and
pheromones. ~Camille Paglia
When I glimpse the backs of women's knees I seem to hear the first movement
of Beethoven's Pastoral Symphony. ~Author Unknown
No woman wants to see herself too clearly. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The
Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
I prefer the word homemaker, because housewife always implies that there may
be a wife someplace else. ~Bella Abzug
Women go to beauty parlors for the unmussed look men hate. ~Mignon
McLaughlin, The Neurotic's Notebook, 1960
Women polish the silver and water the plants and wait to be really needed.
~Mignon McLaughlin, The Neurotic's Notebook, 1960
You have to have the kind of body that doesn't need a girdle in order to get
to pose in one. ~Carolyn Kenmore
There are women who do not like to cause suffering to many men at a time,
and who prefer to concentrate on one man: These are the faithful women.
~Alfred Capus
No matter how good she looks, some other guy is sick and tired of putting up
with her crap. ~Author Unknown
The girls that are always easy on the eyes are never easy on the heart.
~Author Unknown
Men enjoy being thought of as hunters, but are generally too lazy to hunt.
Women, on the other hand, love to hunt, but would rather nobody knew it.
~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
I've reached the age where competence is a turn-on. ~Billy Joel
A man gives many question marks, however, a woman is a whole mystery.
~Diana Strm
You know, women always could endure more than men. Not only physically, but
mentally - did you ever get a peek at some of the husbands? ~Will Rogers
[T]he first time Adam had
a chance he laid the blame on woman. ~Nancy Astor, My Two Countries
God did it on purpose so that we may love you men instead of laughing at
you. ~Mrs. Patrick Campbell, in reply to a male acquaintance who asked why
women seem to have no sense of humor
Men at most differ as Heaven and Earth, but women, worst and best, as Heaven
and Hell. ~Alfred Lord Tennyson
A woman asks little of love: only that she be able to feel like a heroine.
~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
The chief excitement in a woman's life is spotting women who are fatter than
she is. ~Helen Rowland
I would rather trust a woman's instinct than a man's reason. ~Stanley
Baldwin
I should like to know what is the proper function of women, if it is not to
make reasons for husbands to stay at home, and still stronger reasons for
bachelors to go out. ~George Eliot, The Mill on the Floss
Men look at themselves in mirrors. Women look for
themselves. ~Elissa Melamed
If your husband expects you to laugh, do so; if he expects you to cry,
don't; if you don't know what he expects, what are you doing married?
~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
I do not spoil women... I don't send them flowers and gifts... I am saving
those gestures until I am an unpleasant old man who must resort to bribery
to win a woman's synthetic affections. ~George Sanders
Women do not find it difficult nowadays to behave like men, but they often
find it extremely difficult to behave like gentlemen. ~Compton Mackenzie,
Literature in My Time, 1933
Let us leave the beautiful women to men with no imagination. ~Marcel Proust,
Albertine disparue, 1925
Women deserve to have more than twelve years between the ages of
twenty-eight and forty. ~James Thurber, Time, 15 August 1960
Dramatic art in her opinion is knowing how to fill a sweater. ~Bette Davis,
about Jayne Mansfield
A woman's whole life is a history of the affections. ~Washington Irving
Women who make men talk better than they are accustomed to are always
popular. ~E.V. Lucas
I'm not against half naked girls - not as often as I'd like to be. ~Benny
Hill
A man is as good as he has to be, and a woman is as bad as she dares.
~Elbert Hubbard
You should never say anything to a woman that even remotely suggests that
you think she's pregnant unless you can see an actual baby emerging from her
at that moment. ~Dave Barry, "Things That It Took Me 50 Years to Learn"
The supply of good women far exceeds that of the men who deserve them.
~Robert Graves
What men desire is a virgin who is a whore. ~Edward Dahlbert
Women are afraid of mice and of murder, and of very little in between.
~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
A woman should be an illusion. ~Ian Fleming
There are three things men can do with women: love them, suffer for them,
or turn them into literature. ~Stephen Stills
It is because of men that women dislike one another. ~Jean de La Bruyre,
Characters, 1688
Woman didn't get the short end of every stick. At least God gave us
handheld massaging shower heads. ~Rhann Morgan
If you are ever in doubt as to whether to kiss a pretty girl, always give
her the benefit of the doubt. ~Thomas Carlyle
Women who feel naked without their lipstick are well over thirty. ~Mignon
McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
Women are like dogs really. They love like dogs, a little insistently. And
they like to fetch and carry and come back wistfully after hard words, and
learn rather easily to carry a basket. ~Mary Roberts Rinehart
It's the good girls who keep the diaries; the bad girls never have the
time. ~Tallulah Bankhead
A husband only worries about a particular Other Man; a wife distrusts her
whole species. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook,
1966
I believe you should place a woman on a pedestal, high enough so you can
look up her dress. ~Steve Martin
A woman who cannot be ugly is not beautiful. ~Karl Kraus
A man chases a woman until she catches him. ~American Proverb
Variability is one of the virtues of a woman. It avoids the crude
requirement of polygamy. So long as you have one good wife you are sure to
have a spiritual harem. ~G.K. Chesterton, Alarms and Discursions,
1910
Brains are an asset, if you hide them. ~Mae West
With men, as with women, the main struggle is between vanity and comfort;
but with men, comfort often wins. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second
Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
Once a woman has given you her heart, you can never get rid of the rest of
her. ~John Vanbrugh, The Relapse, 1696
Is it too much to ask that women be spared the daily struggle for superhuman
beauty in order to offer it to the caresses of a subhumanly ugly mate?
~Germaine Greer, The Female Eunuch, 1970
A woman can look both moral and exciting... if she also looks as if it was
quite a struggle. ~Edna Ferber
Women have very little idea of how much men hate them. ~Germaine Greer
Do you not know I am a woman? when I think, I must speak. ~William
Shakespeare, As You Like It
Being a woman is of special interest only to aspiring male transsexuals. To
actual women, it is simply a good excuse not to play football. ~Fran
Lebowitz
You're booty-blinded. You know what that is? It's like being snow-blinded
only it ain't no snow, it's a cute little piece of ass. ~From the movie
I Spy
Women are never landlocked: they're always mere minutes away from the briny
deep of tears. ~Mignon McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook,
1966
To get to a woman's heart, a man must first use his own. ~Mike Dobbertin,
quoted in A 5th Portion of Chicken Soup for the Soul
Woman's virtue is man's greatest invention. ~Cornelia Otis Skinner
Nature has given women so much power that the law has very wisely given them
little. ~Samuel Johnson
Women speak two languages - one of which is verbal. ~William Shakespeare
Women are wiser than men because they know less and understand more. ~James
Thurber
I hate women because they always know where things are. ~Voltaire
Good-looking girls break hearts, and goodhearted girls mend them. ~Mignon
McLaughlin, The Second Neurotic's Notebook, 1966
Fighting is essentially a masculine idea; a woman's weapon is her tongue.
~Hermione Gingold
The people I'm furious with are the women's liberationists. They keep
getting up on soapboxes and proclaiming women are brighter than men. That's
true, but it should be kept quiet or it ruins the whole racket. ~Anita
Loos, New York Times, 10 February 1974
Women always worry about the things that men forget; men always worry about
the things women remember. ~Author Unknown
No matter how happily a woman may be married, it always pleases her to
discover that there is a nice man who wishes that she were not. ~H.L.
Mencken